The Naked Warrior vs BJJ Part I
Sometimes I get in trouble in class for using too much power and not enough technique. Both of the schools where I train teach very technical jiu-jitsu. At either place if you spaz out and try to muscle your way through an opponent you’re likely to get barked at. For a long time, I struggled with the balance between technique and power and viewed them as antagonistic goals. In my mind you could either have power or be technical but not both. During this period I was getting crushed on the mat because I was trying to put together sequences without using any strength. I concluded that my technique was poor and I put more and more time into drilling technique. Oddly, my overall game didn’t improve and I continued to find myself overpowered on the mat by guys a lot weaker and smaller than me. I was stuck in this rut for kind of a long time and I was getting kind of discouraged until I discovered Pavel Tsatsouline’s The Naked Warrior.
I bought this book a few months ago when I had to go on an extended business trip. I knew I wouldn’t have access to kettlebells and I wanted to stay fit somehow. I ordered a copy of The Naked Warrior because I was intrigued by the book’s underlying value proposition: namely how to get a killer strength workout using only bodyweight exercises. The book is fascinating in many ways but the most intriguing aspect was a very clear discussion of the conceptual tension between technique and strength. In a nutshell, Pavel says that true strength is technique. In other words, the idea that strength is simply the amount of force you can generate by contracting a muscle is weight-room pseudo-science. In actuality, strength is an outcome of many discrete techniques that applied together, result in unbelievable power. The Naked Warrior program basically breaks down all of these techniques into easily understandable “chunks” that you can put into practice without screwing around in a weight room all day.
There are only two exercises in the Naked Warrior program. The one-arm pushup and the one-legged squat (or pistol). That’s it. After a few months of Naked Warrior training I can do five shaky one-armed pushups on both sides but I still can’t do a real pistol. I can only manage a few pistols by rocking up off a box which is technically cheating, but it’s the best I can do at the moment. But in doing these exercises I’m getting a lot of practice with the various strength techniques contained in the book. There are really too many to cover in this blog post so I’ll just briefly describe the techniques that provided “break-through” moments for me. There are perhaps another dozen techniques in the book, and some of them are frankly beyond my skill level. If you’re interested you can pick up the book from amazon.com.
The anal lock
This technique is exactly what it sounds like. Basically you just clench your sphincter as tight as you can. This is extremely helpful during one-arm pushups because it makes my entire trunk much more rigid. If you’re doing a real one-arm pushup with your shoulders square to the deck you absolutely cannot get off the ground unless your body is rigid.
The armpit corkscrew
The idea here is that if you corkscrew your arm outward from your armpit you will generate much more power than if you just do a regular pressing motion with your arm. If you try it you’ll feel much more tension in your lats and core as those muscles are engaged in the corkscrew motion whereas they are not engaged in a straight-up press.
Pneumatic breathing
This technique had the most dramatic effect on my strength. I always used to inhale on the negative and exhale on the positive while lifting weights. If you employ pneumatic breathing, you keep most of the air in your lungs but let a little bit escape as though through a tiny valve. When you watch boxers you hear them make a sound like “sst sst” or “chh chh” when they punch. That’s pneumatic breathing.
The odd thing about these techniques is that it requires a lot of mental focus to put them all together. If I’m mentally scattered and I try to do a pistol or one-arm pushup I can’t get off the ground. I’ll just stall out in the down position while my face reddens from the strain and I feel like a fool. It’s weird how you can feel power leaking out of your body if you don’t use these techniques. That brings me to another important principle of the Naked Warrior program. Namely, you should never work out to exhaustion. Instead you should do sub-maximal sets many times throughout the day to ensure that you are fresh and mentally focused. Pavel uses the slightly obscene term “Greasing the Groove” to describe this workout pace.
Okay we’re finally getting to the good part. Readers of this blog know I injured my MCL recently. Part of my rehab is to ride an exercise bike. Since I don’t have room for a bike in my crummy apartment I joined 24 hour fitness. Last week after riding the bike I decided to check out the weight room. I haven’t set foot in a weight room since I started BJJ in June of 2007 but just for fun I decided to do some bench presses. I’ve benched the same weight since I was in high school: 4 Olympic plates or 225 pounds, which is basically a bodyweight bench press for me. Not too impressive. After an extended absence from the weight room I thought I might be able to squeeze out a couple of reps at that weight. Instead I easily did 3 sets of 7 reps. I was stunned. I wasn’t even breathing hard. So on a lark I loaded on two more Olympic plates which is my former one-rep maximum of 315 pounds and I was able to squeeze out another 7 reps. I couldn’t frickin believe it.
After thinking it through I realized that I had been unconsciously employing the Naked Warrior techniques. During the press my feet were barely touching the ground because I had been unconsciously doing the anal lock. My trunk was so rigid that my legs were elevated bringing my feet with them. I also realized that I had been doing pneumatic breathing. I never utilized these techniques before, because I didn’t know that they existed. So in a somewhat trivial and unscientific way the Naked Warrior routine was validated for me. It seems that strength really is a function of technique. I should also add that my physique is particularly unimpressive at the moment. I used to have a big chest and arms but those pretty much went away when I stopped lifting weights. Sadly my gut is as prominent as ever.
Anyway I was kind of stoked to see if I could reproduce this success with squats but due to my MCL issue I decided to take it easy rather than run the risk of aggravating my injury. I did do a few sets of squats with low weight but I don’t have anything remarkable to add other than I wasn’t breathing too hard which I would expect working out at that weight. When my leg is better I should try to beat my one-rep squat max but I don’t know when that will be.
Part II of this blog will discuss the question, “Does max strength even matter in BJJ?”
March 20th, 2008 at 1:37 pm
Solid information Crosschoke.
I haven’t tried the exercises that you discuss in your post, however, I have used the Combat Conditioning exercises by Matt Furey to some degree of success. The Hindu squat is a good workout when I have access to nothing else.
Since my epiphany last week I have contemplated joining a gym and may do so soon. I like bodyweight exercises too and prefer circuit training if I do lift weights, but I think that I may have to use a more traditional method as well. Like you, I also maintain a bench in the high 200s without working on it, but for my weight division the bigger guys probably can do the same or more and I can’t keep wingin’ it in that category.
March 21st, 2008 at 4:43 pm
That’s awesome, TK! That must have been thrilling to see how much strength you’ve gained! And with an injury, too—you are a manimal, mister.
March 26th, 2008 at 4:28 pm
[…] weight range of 200 and up I can’t neglect strength. As I mentioned in a response to one of Crosschoke’s posts, I can hit the high 200s in a bench press without lifting weights for significant periods of time. […]
March 27th, 2008 at 2:50 pm
Interesting post.
I’ve never been a strength player, and we have the same attitude towards guys who try to muscle stuff on in our gym (ie they get bawled at).
I’m 170lbs, and am lucky in that I get to roll with many other people my size and smaller, so I can really develop my technical skills. But with two exceptions, all the other purple belts and up at my gym at 185lbs+. I suffer going head to head with them because their size and strength do make things difficult.
I resolved to up my physical conditioning, which I’ve done using principles of websites like crossfit. I’ll do a proper blog post about it soon, but in the meantime there is a little bit about it over in my latest post
March 31st, 2008 at 10:53 pm
Dude, this is absolutely fascinating. It makes sense that body mechanics might have such a huge impact, but you actually experienced - which is really amazing. Well done, amigo!
I have had Pavel’s book on my wish list on Amazon.com for a few months. I should man-up and buy it.
May 1st, 2008 at 5:47 am
[…] Now I do not own a copy of the book, but read a whole bunch of useful and insightful reviews and posts on the book. (ah, how I love the […]
May 1st, 2008 at 8:31 pm
Of course absolute strength matters! It is the foundational quality upon which all other strength related bio-motor abilities rely!
-speed
-power
-endurance
all will be enhanced by higher levels of force production capacity.